Sherlock Hound vol. 1
 Dave Merrill  rates it:    

What can I say about a show that features anthropomorphic animal versions of human beings having adventures - without sounding like one who's joined the Furry Revolution, I mean? Well, two words may serve to relieve the discomfort bubbling up through your pyloric valve- HAYAO MIYAZAKI. Yeah, that's right, Comrade Nausicaa himself, together with Tokyo Movie Shinsha and the Italian TV company RAI, produced this animated, walking, talking dog version of England's own Sherlock Holmes. Kind of takes the stench of "yiff" away, doesn't it?

Originally known as Famous Detective Holmes, this show was one of the mysterious gray areas of Miyazaki's resume; we knew he worked on it, but we didn't know when and where and for how long, and more importantly, we couldn't get good copies of the darn things. Well, Pioneer has heard our pleas and released Holmes on a series of 2-sided DVDs. Side One has five episodes in English, and the other side has the same exact episodes in Japanese, with subtitles. Extensive research has determined that the English versions of these episodes come from the same bunch that Just For Kids released on cheap, 6-hour, KayBee Toys Clearance Bin Home Video several years ago. You may have noticed them taking up shelf space next to their Macron One releases.

This dub is, however, not the English dub that certain sharp-eyed anime fans may have remembered seeing on the Showtime cable channel years ago - that version featured a Sherlock Holmes that was, in fact, referred to as "Holmes", as well as British accents that might be a tad more authentic, for the simple fact that they might actually be voiced by British people. This edition is perfectly acceptable, however. The dubbing is Englishy enough, the transfer is excellent, and we're even given the original Japanese opening and ending credits. The box itself is really classy, and the liner notes reveal several interesting things about the production of Holmes; namely, that the show was a 1981 co-production between TMS and RAI, originally produced in English, and it was cancelled after 4 Miyazaki-directed episodes, and then two other Miyazaki episodes were completed and shown on a double bill with Nausicaa, and then they went and got Kyosuke Mikuriya to make twenty MORE episodes for the 1984 TV season. And now I've given all the surprises away.

But even if you know all its secrets, Hound is still a DVD worth watching. I know that there are those among us who shudder at the thought of a period cartoon starring talking dogs. I am one of those people. I prefer my anthropomorphic canines to stick to late-night poker games. However, if you can't trust Hayao to turn even the most unpromising premise into entertainment, who can you trust? Nobody, that's who. Hound is full of the kind of detailed, hyper-kinetic set-piece action scenes that made Miyazaki memorable. The characters - canine as they may be - are as fully realized as cartoon characters can be, from facial expressions to clothes to nervous habits. And the backgrounds! Somebody at TMS did their homework, because this show features some of the (a) most accurate and (b) most beautiful background work I've ever seen in an animated television show. Edwardian London literally comes to life; crowded city streets, train stations, department stores and government offices and the ramshackle apartments on Baker Street where Holmes and Watson relax between cases - all are realistically and vividly portrayed. Virtually every shot is crammed full of period detail. Other, lesser cartoons would suffocate under such baggage; Hound thrives on it.

That's not to say this show is an exercise in historical accuracy. Great liberties are taken with regards to mechanical contrivances; especially those of a certain Professor Moriarty, the self-styled 'Napoleon Of Crime', whose wizardry at late 19th century gadgetry would only be matched by the similar antics of the character Grandis from Gainax's 1991 series Nadia: Secret of Blue Water. Not that I would point the finger of plagarisim at that much-and-justly-maligned series - no, the animation that was shameless in its theft from Hound would be Disney's own Great Mouse Detective, which managed to crowbar entire scenes from Sherlock Hound - and what it didn't steal from Hound, it swiped from Castleof Cagliostro. But I digress. Suffice to say that Hound is probably the only show that can utilize painstaking recreations of Victoria Station circa 1901 and Space Invaders sight gags.

Why only the Japanese and the Italians could produce the quintessential Sherlock Holmes cartoon is a question better left answered by semiotics professors or popular culture majors, and why it stars talking dogs is probably not going to be touched except by somebody's overpaid psychologist. Why the whole mess works is a completely different story altogether. While not as thrill-intensive as your typical robot cartoon or sci-fi epic, Hound succeeds with its own brand of tweedy, low-key adventure.

That's not to say that everybody's going to find Hound a masterpiece. Sherlock Holmes fans, in particular, aren't going to be very impressed, because as near as I can figure Hound doesn't actually feature any of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's actual Sherlock Holmes stories. I don't particularly consider this a deal-killer - how many Lupin III episodes are based on Leblanc's actual Lupin stories? - but it's refreshing to see a show obsessed with background accuracy yet blissfully unconcerned about actually giving us a Red-Headed League, or for that matter, a Hound of the Baskervilles. Yet, comparing Hound with Holmes gives us some insight into the transformation from human sleuth to dog detective. The human Holmes is, to be blunt, kind of a jerk. He's an arrogant know-it-all with a big nose; tough to wrap a children's cartoon around, to be sure. I certainly can't see Doyle's Holmes spending time with children the way Miyazaki's Hound does. However, let's face facts; if I was a big fan of nineteenth-century English literature, I wouldn't be reviewing many Japanese cartoons.

Even though this DVD features very little in the way of extras or special goodies - very little meaning, absolutely nothing - the quality of the animation and the charm of the show itself make Sherlock Hound well worth sniffing out.

Added:  Saturday, October 18, 2003

Related Link:  Pioneer Animation
hits: 4456